|
|
|
By Kelley
Smith, Senior VP of Kensington Realty Advisors
Reprint from Real Estate Chicago: June 2001
Recently,
theres been a fair amount of debate about investments in senior
housing, and whether this property type should be included in an investors
real estate portfolio. The questions about senior housing can be answered,
but not without a few definitions first:
Age-Restricted and Independent Living: Residents live independently
in age-restricted apartments.
Congregate Senior Housing: Residents live in private or semi-private
areas, share recreational facilities, meals (one to three per day), and
common areas.
Assisted Living: All of the above, but residents need a higher
degree of personal care and assistance with daily living.
Skilled Nursing: These facilities are equipped to handle residents
with intensive medical care needs that are more akin to hospital standards.
As we all know, the U.S. population is aging and the baby boom is leading
the pack, but where is demand currently and where will it be in the future?
There are now about 45.5 million Americans who are 60 or older, and this
age group is growing at a much faster rate than the population as a whole.
As the baby boomers age, the growth rate of the elderly population will
accelerate further, so by 2015 its estimated that there will be
more than 64.5 million people over the age of 60, an increase of 44%.
More specifically, the largest population bulge will be in the 60-69 age
group, a segment expected to grow nearly 70% by the year 2015. The 70-79
age group is the next largest, with growth expectations of 15% by 2015.
Finally, the over 80 group is expected to grow 30% in the next 15 years.
In addition to a simple growth rate, the supply of potential senior housing
residents is large due to medical improvements that have increased life
expectancy, and a better awareness of health issues.
While theres no question that there will be plenty of prospective
residents for senior housing, how many will make the decision to choose
a senior housing facility? There are many factors that influence this
choice, and each individual will weigh these factors differently. It should
be noted that in many cases there is no choice or a choice
is a perception versus a reality. Data shows that for those over 85 years
old, a higher percentage actually live in senior housing (10.9%) than
those who plan to move to senior housing (2.5%).
Its also interesting to note that lower-income households choose
senior housing more than higher-income households. Those with higher incomes
can afford in-home assistance and or to hire other services such as transportation
more readily than those with lower incomes. In addition, many seniors
find that they prefer to be in the company of their peers and are drawn
to the community offered in a senior housing environment.
The returns generated by senior housing are attractive to investors. A
comparison of median going-in (cash-on-cash) rates of the various senior
housing and apartments (using no leverage) found apartments at 8.5%, age-restricted
independent at 9%, congregate at 10%, and assisted living at 11%. A property
that blends some or all of the above, to transition residents as the need
arises, is called continuing care retirement community (CCRC), which is
at 10.5%. Note that class A senior housing properties will trade at cap
rates below these numbers. Furthermore, in the current environment, the
returns would be enhanced by the use of leverage.
Based on our research, we believe that there are many real estate investment
opportunities in age-restricted independent living, congregate, and assisted
living senior housing. Given the demographics, we also think the current
demand will be for age-restricted apartment communities, which will move
in the future toward congregate and assisted living housing.
Its a unique opportunity. As people get older and have increasing
health needs, more income will be directed to health expenditures and
less toward investment or consumption of other goods. In addition, compared
with other property types, senior housing isnt significantly affected
by technology risk and is less volatile overall, marked by high occupancy,
solid rent growth (average 4% per year), and relatively low turnover.
|
|